Breakfast Buffet

Lesley’s Homestyle Cafe & Catering

By Angie Fenton

I grew up in a small town and have

always loved locally-owned restaurants that embrace “downhome

cooking” – added bonus if that also means including

a bit of healthy fare on the menu, too. So, when friend Paul

Kiger invited me and my family to New Middletown, Indiana,

to enjoy breakfast at Lesley’s Homestyle Cafe & Catering, we

were all in.

The drive from New Albany took a little more than 20 minutes

and was beautiful, especially once we got off I-64 West. (If

you opt to take the Ohio River Scenic Byway, the drive is even

prettier and will only take about 30 minutes.)

The town may be small – population 93, according to the

2010 census – but the hospitality offered to visitors looms

large. We were warmly greeted at Lesley’s Homestyle Cafe &

Catering by employees and our fellow diners. Owner Lesley

McPhillips (who also happens to be Paul’s sister) and her team

are visible from the dining room as they whip up all kinds of

goodies, wash dishes and greet guests. Known for her catering,

there are lots of us who are thankful she decided to open up a

brick ’n‘ mortar eatery.

My husband, our 2-year-old and I enjoyed the Breakfast

Buffet ($8.50), which had a variety of dishes, including fluffy

eggs, biscuits, sausage gravy, perfectly cooked bacon and

fresh fruit, among other items. Everything was delicious and

freshly made. Now, despite the fact that it was morning and

far too early for dessert – plus, I’d done a decent job of eating

healthfully – I ordered a slice of the Strawberry Delight Cake

($2.75) anyway because I’d been told it was a can’t-miss sweet

made with love by Linda Windell (Lesley and Paul’s mother).

That couldn’t be truer. Try the cake.

Lesley’s Homestyle Cafe & Catering is open 11 a.m. to 8 p.m.

Tuesday, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Friday and Saturday and 8 a.m. to 4

p.m. Sunday. The breakfast buffet is served 8 a.m. to 12 p.m.

Saturday and Sunday. Keep an eye on the Facebook page to stay

up-to-date on the happenings. Recent highlights have included

ribeye steak dinners cooked however you please, Taco Tuesday,

a Friday night seafood bar and an Italian-themed menu.

screen-shot-2018-03-07-at-10-47-38-am screen-shot-2018-03-07-at-10-47-41-am

Do you have a favorite dish at a Southern Indiana

restaurant that you can’t wait to share with others? Send an

email detailing why to and put “The

Cheat Sheet” as the subject.

Lesley’s Homestyle Cafe & Catering

3975 Main St.

New Middletown, Indiana


@cateringlesley on Facebook

Leave a Comment:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *